Chelsea Green author Bob Cavnar and DailyKos diarist Fishgrease join us to discuss the British Petroleum oil disaster that took place a year ago yesterday.  Bob also wrote an op-ed for the Houston Chronicle that ran yesterday.

There were several other painful realities that became apparent during the disaster of last summer. First, the industry did not know how to contain a deep-water blowout. Second, it is still using 40-year-old oil cleanup technology. And third, blowout preventers have a high failure rate. Unfortunately, having witnessed the results of these hard lessons, we still haven’t done much to correct these failures. To be sure, there are companies now being formed to do deep-water containment. In typical fashion, though, the effort is diluted, with smaller companies utilizing Helix Energy Services, a private, for-profit operation, and the majors forming a co-op called the Marine Well Containment Company. It’s unclear what will happen in the next accident, such as who pays if a small operator goes bankrupt after a large spill, not a trivial matter. Some advances will come eventually in spill cleanup, but will be slow unless the government takes a leading role, which, so far it is wont to do.

Which leaves us with the blowout preventer. Everyone in the industry has known for years that blowout preventers have a high failure rate, but no one really focused on that failure rate until the BP blowout. The recent forensics report from Det Norske Veritas on the Deepwater Horizon blowout preventer probably raised more questions than it answered, especially after managers for the study admitted to flaws in its own computer models that led to its conclusions and recommendations. The solution from the industry and the federal government? Let’s go back to work with no fundamental changes or redesign, depending completely on the subsea well containment companies when the next failure occurs.

The last year has been an odyssey where the disaster in the Gulf led many to hope that finally we were going to focus on a comprehensive energy policy, improve safety and protect the environment. To the disappointment of many, including me, none of these objectives was reached; indeed, they are not even being contemplated as all of our politicians, having just finished a re-election cycle a few months ago, are gearing up for the next one that comes a little over a year from now. We don’t want to let trivial things like protecting human life and the environment interfere with the game of politics, do we? It seems that, even in the face of catastrophe, we really haven’t learned any of the important lessons we desperately need to learn.

This failure to face up to the inevitability of a recurrence of a serious deepwater oil spill is systemic.

Of course, spills happen on land, too. I’ve spent a lot of time in Bradford County, Pennsylvania–where there was a fracking spill on the Horizon disaster anniversary.

One Response to Anniversary

  1. Sherry Reson says:

    Virtually Speaking has IRC. Internet Relay Chat allows listeners on the web to participate in the studio audience chat from another browser window. Here’s how
    1. Connect to
    2. Enter a name for yourself (the system will remember it the next time you use it.)
    3. Enter #vspeak into the channel field.
    4. While listening to a live program on BlogTalkRadio, type comments and questions into the IRC text field at the bottom of your screen. Read what others write.
    5. Begin your question with ‘QUESTION’ so it’s easy for the host to spot.

    NOTE: ‘Relay Rinq’ is not a person but the bridge signature to IRC chat.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: